Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Bayside Bakery & Cafe
Welcome to Bayside Bakery & Cafe, a delightful gem located at 108 First St Suite B in Port St. Joe, Florida. This charming establishment isn't just a bakery; it’s a haven for lovers of quality baked goods and exceptional coffee. With a commitment to freshness and flavor, every item here is crafted with care and creativity, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and travelers alike.
As you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked pastries envelops you. From their stunning cakes, perfect for life's special moments, to rich quiches and scrumptious sandwiches, there is something for everyone. The customer reviews reflect a consistent theme of satisfaction and joy—one visitor noted, “They did a wonderful job on my sister's birthday cake! Beautiful and delicious!” This dedication to both looks and taste is what sets Bayside apart.
The cafe also prides itself on serving the best coffee in the area, with beans roasted just 30 minutes away. Patrons rave about the quality, particularly appreciating the use of Monin syrups that elevate each cup. A satisfied customer commented, “This is the better coffee in this area so far,” highlighting the cafe’s dedication to superior ingredients and flavors.
Let’s not overlook the pastries! A blueberry danish might just be the perfect companion to that morning brew. Another guest remarked on the lovely assortment of pastries, quiche, and cakes, noting that “everything is always fresh and tastes soooo good.” The blend of taste and artistry in each creation makes every bite a celebration.
What truly enhances the experience at Bayside Bakery & Cafe is the warmth of its team. Reviewers consistently mention the friendly and accommodating staff who genuinely care about making each customer’s visit special. Whether it’s tweaking an iced espresso to your liking or ensuring that your cakes are perfect for your celebrations, their commitment to customer satisfaction shines through.
Each wedding cake, birthday cake, and pastry isn’t just a product; it’s a part of your story. Rimma Pennington aptly described her wedding cake as “the best” and spoke about how guests couldn’t stop talking about it, emphasizing the emotional connection created through food. This personal touch and attention to detail truly set Bayside Bakery & Cafe apart.
If you find yourself in Port St. Joe, make sure to stop by this local treasure. Whether for a quick coffee break, a leisurely brunch, or that perfect cake for your next occasion, Bayside Bakery & Cafe promises a delightful experience that you will remember—and likely return for. With every bite, you’ll taste the passion that goes into each creation, making it an unforgettable part of your culinary journey.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ They did a wonderful job on my sisters birthday cake! Beautiful and delicious!!!! ”
“ This is the better coffee in this area so far. Monin syrups are definitely a step up, the coffee is roasted about 30 min away. The blueberry danish was good, pastries, quiche and cakes looked great. Employees were friendly. A good spot to sit a moment and enjoy baked goods. ”
“ Called 3 weeks ahead about ordering 2 cakes for Memorial Day Week to celebrate my Wife's and Daughter’s birthday. Called back upon arrival to cape san blas to make sure there were no issues. They answered everytime I called, always pleasent, made sure of correct date, names, and cake theme. I picked my cakes up 5/28/25 and they were perfect exactly how I ordered, they were delicious and decorated beautifully. I got one 8 inch and one 6 inch we fed 11 people multiple times and brought some home. I always support local and I would recommend this bakery to anyone that is near port st joe or visiting. We'll definitely be back. Thank You for making both my Girls birthday special!!!! 5 Stars ”
“ We were here for a family trip and came upon this little bakery. The pastries are yummy. But also A for my iced expresso. It was perfection as she accommodated to what I wanted in it. Amazing team. Haven’t gotten to try the cakes but from the views of them, they looked beautiful. Highly recommend this little shop when you are in Port Saint Joe. I love small businesses who are willing to meet customers needs. I’ll be coming back for sure. ”
“ Mikayla and her team are so helpful and everything they make at their bakery is absolutely delicious! We tried everything from their lunch sandwiches to key lime pies and gluten free brownies and macaroons. Everything is always fresh and tastes soooo good. But the most incredible thing we have tried was our wedding cake that these guys made for us! Just wow! Vanilla cake with strawberry filling and some delicious cookies on a side. Our wedding guests wouldn’t stop talking about this cake! Hundred percent the best! Thank you for making our special day extra special!!! ”
“ This bakery is simply a delight! I ordered my daughters fishing birthday cake from GA. With a pick up this past Friday. The cake was perfect. Delicious and adorable. But the bakery and its owner were nothing less than a small town touchdown. (Reference because it was homecoming this weekend. Cheerleaders were waiting the parade in the bakery.). We couldn’t resist the baked goodies and chicken salad. Both were perfect for coffee and fishing boat treats. This will be our go to place for all things bakery. Thank you again for loving our daughter so well!! Her birthday cake was just what her fishing heart wanted! ”
“ Ordered a birthday cake for my husband from Bayside Bakery last year and he still talks about how good it was!! The caramel filling was AMAZING! We are coming back down to Port St Joe again this year for his birthday and will be ordering another cake from here. Highly recommend! ”
“ All the employees are always so pleasant. Their coffee is the best I love trying their new daily coffees. Their blueberry muffins are wonderful and chocolate chip as well as their chicken salad and from time to time there they have the chocolate covered strawberries. Definitely try their chocolate covered strawberry Coffee. They’re all around the best in town. ”